CAG report is not the final word on any issue: Supreme Court
- Multiple cities put on high alert amid terror threat
- With BJP raising ‘the enemy within’, silent opposition pushed to the wall
- NJAC case: Factor in merit, integrity in choosing judges, Government tells SC
- Vijay Mallya default case: Debt Recovery Tribunal to pass order today
- Pak NSA warned Doval of 26/11-type hit on Shivratri
CAG report commands respect and cannot be brushed aside but it cannot be the final word on an issue, the Supreme Court said today while noting that the auditor's findings cannot be gospel truth as it is subject to scrutiny by Parliament.
A bench of justices K S Radhakrishnan and Dipak Misra said that CAG's report is always subject to parliamentary debates and it is possible that Public Accounts Committee (PAC) can accept the objection to the report or reject it.
"The CAG's report is always subject to parliamentary debates and it is possible that PAC can accept the ministry's objection to the CAG report or reject the report of the CAG. The CAG, indisputably is an independent constitutional functionary. However, it is for Parliament to decide whether after receiving the report to make its comments on it," the court said.
The bench made the observations while rejecting CAG views on Cairn-Vedanta deal, saying that "it is factually and legally incorrect and cannot be accepted".
The bench analysed various provisions pertaining to CAG functioning and said, "We have come across several instances where considerable reliance has been placed on the CAG Report projecting it as gospel truth".
The court's remarks assumes significance in the wake of the recent controversy over CAG's figure of the estimated loss to public exchequer due to coal blocks and 2G spectrum allocation scams.
"We have referred to the report of the CAG, the role of the PAC and the procedure followed in the House, only to indicate that the CAG report is always subject to scrutiny by Parliament and Government can always offer its views on the report of the CAG," the bench said.
"We may, however, point out that since the report is from a constitutional functionary, it commands respect and cannot be brushed aside as such, but it is equally important to examine the comments what respective ministries have to offer on the CAG's report.
- In JNU, as in HCU, gullible students are being targeted by forces inimical to the country
- Haryana government must remember: Investors stay away when property can’t be secured
- Despite Oli’s claim that he went to Delhi with no list, the trip is being scrutinised
- The petroleum industry is in poor shape. Budget 2016 fails to lay out a clear roadmap
- There is an opportunity for a global treaty to balance security concerns and privacy
- The way to improve the farmer’s income is to improve his non-farm income.