Dying declaration not sole criteria for conviction: HC
- Gujarat to SC: Woman knew of snooping, was thankful
- Rahul Gandhi 'happy' with Varun Gandhi's 'good work' praise; BJP leader clarifies it's no endorsement for Cong
- April 2 Campaign roundup: Congress trying to spread communal disharmony ahead of polls, says Arun Jaitley
- Nitish Katara murder case: Delhi HC says Katara's killers to stay in jail for life; calls it honour killing
- Mahendra Singh Dhoni is not higher than the game of cricket: Zee to HC
The Bombay High Court has observed that a dying declaration cannot be the sole criteria for conviction and in case of two contrasting views, the one favourable to the accused should be adopted.
A division Bench of Justices Pratap Hardas and Ashok Bhangale said, "The criminal court has to bear in mind that if two views are possible upon the evidence led – one pointing towards guilt of the accused while the other towards his innocence – then the one favourable to the accused should be adopted to prevent miscarriage of justice which can result by conviction of an innocent."
On this basis, the Nagpur bench of the court acquitted a woman who was accused of killing another woman by setting her on fire.
On October 14 last year, Sharifabi (66), from Amravati, was convicted by a sessions court for setting on fire Shaydabi, following which the latter died.
Sharifabi was sentenced to life imprisonment, based on the deceased's dying declaration.
However, she challenged the verdict in High Court and her counsel Rajendra Daga contended that the trial court had erred in relying solely on the dying declaration as there was no witness or other evidence to corroborate it.
While the incident occurred at around 2 pm, the dying declaration was recorded at 8.15 PM, indicating a huge time gap. "The time lapse gives scope for tutoring, prompting and imagination," she said.
The bench was also of the view that there was no witness or evidence to show Sharifabi's bad motive. Until and unless the dying declaration is truthful and voluntary and not tutored or doctored, conviction solely on that basis is not possible, it said.
"The court must be satisfied that the deceased was in a fit mental state to make the declaration and must ensure that the dying declaration was not the result of tutoring, prompting or imagination," the judges said.
- ‘Fake’ MBA admission: Iranian girl untraceable as cops busy with polls
- To avoid election duty, teachers flock to doctors to get medical certificates
- Arun Bhatia hopes to get third time lucky
- Congress complains against Narendra Modi for poll code violation
- Flying squads deployed to check flow of liquor and gifts yet to spot offenders
- Flaunt the indelible ink on your finger, and get freebies