Letter and spirit
- Hyderabad University on the boil: 'Kanhaiya won't be allowed to enter HCU campus'
- Brussels attack: Two suspects identified as Khalid and Brahim Bakraoui
- No achche din: PM Modi under fire as middle class hit hard due to rising costs
- Chhattisgarh: Latest journalist arrest is for a WhatsApp dig at a cop
- Mehbooba Mufti set to be J&K CM after meeting with PM Modi
Muslim insecurity is all too real, but Shinde's letter reduces it to a political talking point.
Union Home Minister Sushilkumar Shinde has been roundly attacked for his letter to chief ministers, where he asked them to ensure no Muslim was wrongfully detained in terror cases. BJP president Rajnath Singh has asked for the letter be withdrawn for its "unconstitutional" premise, and others have questioned the propriety of the home minister singling out a minority group in this manner, because all citizens are equally entitled to justice. Earlier, Shinde had announced fast-track courts for terror cases involving Muslims, prompting the criticism that these cases need impartial investigation and swift justice, not gestures to a religious group.
Shinde's point may be valid, given the substantive inequality of minority communities. In many states, the Muslim presence in prison is disproportionate to their share in the population. This is not just in terror cases, but also for a range of other smaller crimes — either because of the reflexive suspicion of law enforcers, or because deprivation and crime are linked. And when it comes to terror investigations, there is a strong sense in the community that Muslims are targeted by police and ATS forces across states. This has been borne out by impartial observers. In Uttar Pradesh, the R.D. Nimesh commission revealed holes in the state's special task force investigations on serial blasts in Faizabad, Barabanki and Lucknow. In 2006, Imran Kirmani was held for a "9/11-type plot" in Delhi, until freed four years later by the court, which commented on the "callous and inferior quality of investigation". Hundreds of Muslims were arrested without proof after the 2006 Mumbai attacks, when the ATS and Mumbai Police could not reconcile their stories. Nine Muslim men were imprisoned for the Malegaon blasts, and freed after five years when they were found to be innocent. In other words, the problem is real —- social prejudice, unexamined biases within police and judiciary, the official stakes in quick answers and the special laws that operate in terror cases make for a bad combination.
- Veterans of the Assam Movement now fight polls. But the bitterness and the issues linger on
- When Bhagat Singh’s clarion call ‘Inquilab Zindabad’, it was voluntarily accepted
- Delhi needs an authority suitably empowered and responsible for safe drinking water
- And what are Kanhaiya's credentials for being catapulted to this superhero status?
- In Bangladesh’s diminishing democratic space, a prominent editor is at the receiving end
- Supreme Court has the opportunity to enforce the true Islamic law on divorce