Not another law
- Target Uttar Pradesh: Modi goes to Varanasi, Rajnath to Lucknow
- TRS rules out alliance with Cong in LS, assembly polls
- SC stays death penalty of two Delhi gang-rape convicts till March 31
- AICC spokesman lashes out against PM's silence and negative publicity
- Court imposes fine of Rs 2,500 each on Arvind Kejriwal, Manish Sisodia
New legislation for dispute resolution may not be the best way to move infrastructure projects stuck in courts
The prime minister's directive to the Planning Commission, to draft a new legislation for setting up an institutional mechanism to resolve disputes in public contracts, may not be the best answer to a pressing problem. Indeed, creating a new law may even be seen as a convenient way of sidestepping the failures of the bureaucracy and the prevailing dispute resolution systems. The proposal for this draft law stems from the large number of infrastructure projects stuck in the courts, which are seen to be responsible for the decline in investment and growth. The solution, according to the PMO, lies in setting up a dedicated institutional mechanism, on the lines of the tribunal system, and eliminating litigation up to the high court.
This proposal provokes several concerns. To begin with, it ignores the inefficiencies of the project authorities, which often delay administrative and implementation procedures relating to PPPs. Two, in bypassing judicial delays faced at the high-court level by going down the tribunal route, it fails to acknowledge the troubles inherent in the tribunal system itself. Three, doing away with quasi-judicial arbitration mechanisms comes at the cost of improvements in what has emerged as a moderately successful alternate dispute resolution mechanism in India in the recent past. Four, drafting a new legislation does not wish away the reality of the bureaucratic and administrative incapacities that will likely beset even this new arrangement.
- BJP projected to sweep Gujarat, Rajasthan, Karnataka; Congress to get big jolt in Maharashtra
- Editors body slams Arvind Kejriwal for ‘irresponsible’ media remark, says it is a sign of ‘weakness’
- Trouble in alliance with Congress, TRS turns to BJP
- Minority panel removed my riot report against Modi: Ex-Secy