SC rejects UP govt plea on lawyers’ contracts
- GST Bill in Rajya Sabha this week, Jaitley to discuss amendments with state finance ministers
- Narsingh Yadav fails dope test, Rio 2016 Olympics participation under threat
- AAP MLA Amanatullah Khan arrested for threatening a woman
- Kin of missing AN-32 passengers, crew: Across the country, they wait for word, hoping and praying
- Kashmir unrest: Of 317 with pellet injuries in action by CRPF, over 50% have been hit in eye
In a setback to the Uttar Pradesh government, the Supreme Court has dismissed a batch of its appeals against the Allahabad High Court verdicts, which had set aside its decision against renewing its contracts with lawyers appointed in various districts.
"Total non-application of mind and the order being supported by no reason whatsoever would render the order passed as arbitrary. Arbitrariness shall vitiate the administrative order," Justices Swatanter Kumar and Sudhansu Jyoti Mukhopadhaya said while upholding the decisions of the High Court.
"The arbitrary act of the state cannot be excluded from the ambit of judicial review merely on the ground that it is a contractual matter," Justice Kumar, writing the verdict for the bench, said.
The UP government, in as many as 18 appeals, had assailed various judgments of the Lucknow bench of the Allahabad High Court, which had set aside its decisions not to renew the contracts of government lawyers after expiry of their terms.
"The order (of UP) dated April 3, 2008, is even liable to be quashed on another ground, that it is a non-speaking order also suffering from the vice of non-application of mind. As already discussed, the government has taken an en-block decision, without recording any reason, not to renew the term of any of the government counsel. That itself shows that there is no application of mind," the apex court said and rejected the appeals of the state government.
Declining to "interfere" with the High Court verdicts, it asked the state to consider and decide within three months the lawyers' pleas for renewal of their contracts under the rules prescribed on the issue.
The rules provide "a procedure and even require the state government to consider the case for renewal of the government counsel whose term is coming to an end," the court said.
- The recent violence against Dalits in Gujarat is a fallout of the Sangh Parivar’s diktats on food
- Turkey’s coup reveals the fragile relationship between Islam and democracy
- The Sangh Parivar has furthered the colonial understanding of India’s past
- Better state support and supportive social environment can help independent filmmakers
- Next Door Nepal: Chinese checkers
- Kashmir unrest: A to-do list for PM Modi